
I’ve listened through most of the Owl City songs, and I finally figured out what’s been bothering me about the sound, and it’s not auto-tune. Surprising? I thought so. It’s easy to point at auto-tune as the culprit for formulaic pop music sounding bad because it’s distinctive; when you modify voices in post-production, it’s the first thing music fans are going to notice. But auto-tune works here, so what’s the problem?
Issue #1: Lyrical content
This is a slightly-altered version of my rant to Kyle about Owl City lyrics.
To make an Owl City track, add:
- One part “Calllliforrrrnia” or another whimsical locale
- One part mountains/hills/sky
- Two to four parts metaphors for love
- Two parts description of “seeing her” or “meeting her”
- One part weather
- One to three parts normally obscure everyday object(s)
- Mix the above with pared-down background beat and auto-tune
-
You can test your favorite Owl City songs, you’ll see a pattern developing.
Issue #2: Emotion in the sound
This is a more important issue, and don’t confuse “emotion” here with “emo” music and the like. Most songs I listen to have built-in emotion in the swelling and shrinking of background music, the energy in the lead’s vocals, and quick changes of rhythm and pitch at key moments. Obviously not all songs have all of the things above, but in general, you can identify where the substance of the work has been established.
Owl City missed this, plain and simple. The vast majority of the songs start at one volume and end at that volume. They start with the same auto-tuned, happy-go-lucky sound of Adam Young’s voice that stays exactly the same tonally for the duration. The only change might be the addition of an extra synth or layer of electronic drums to indicate “this is the chorus now.” In general, listening to this stuff might make great background music, because it doesn’t stand out on its own. It’s also no surprise that Fireflies elicited a “that’s not bad” response from me when I first heard it; it might be the most emotional song the band has produced.
I guess it’s just not my style.
Fireflies Video: http://bit.ly/7wLaqk
Owl City On Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Owl_city






0 Comments